When “American Idol” judge Kara DioGuardi spoke to PEOPLE for the Most Beautiful People issue in May, she admitted that her fiancé, Mike McCuddy, loves her sans makeup. “He’s from Maine,” she explained. “He likes that earthy girl, just-out-of-the-shower look.”

It was fitting then, that DioGuardi, 38, looked radiant on July 5 in Prospect, Maine, at her wedding to McCuddy, 34, a general contractor.

“They were married at the Prospect Harbor United Methodist Church,” confirms a rep for DioGuardi, who added that the bride wore a Vera Wang dress.